TL;DR
Get audio and creator gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Andy Richter says U2 guitarist the Edge wrote a sequel to the 2003 holiday film Elf and that producer Shauna Robertson was approached about the project. Richter has not described its plot, and no clear reason has emerged for why it was not made.
Actor and comedian Andy Richter says U2’s the Edge wrote a sequel to Elf, the 2003 Christmas comedy, but the project was never made. Richter described the reported script in interviews with The Daily Beast’s Obsessed podcast and Page Six Radio, though he did not explain its story or give a clear reason it did not proceed.
Richter, who had a small role in the original film, told Obsessed podcast host Matt Wilstein that Canadian producer Shauna Robertson had been approached about a sequel written by the musician. He later recounted the story while speaking with Page Six Radio, according to Stereogum’s report. The podcast discussion appears at about the 31-minute mark of its video, the outlet said.
Richter’s account suggests the project was more than a passing idea: he said the sequel was reportedly fully written. But he did not share a plot outline, say when the script was written, or clarify whether Robertson or anyone else formally developed it. The available account does not establish that a studio approved the project or that production was scheduled.
Stereogum reported that there was no clear explanation for why the sequel failed to come to fruition, beyond Richter’s indication that things did not work out. No statement from the Edge, Robertson, or the film’s studio is included in the source material. The reported script’s existence and history therefore rest on Richter’s account.
A Sequel Script Without a Film
The story adds an unexpected detail to the history of a film that has become a regular part of many viewers’ holiday routines. A sequel reportedly written by the Edge would have joined the original movie’s established creative world with a musician not commonly associated with writing a Hollywood comedy. For fans, the revelation offers a glimpse of a possible continuation that never reached the screen.
It also illustrates the difference between a completed script and a completed film. Richter’s description points to a written project and an approach to a producer, but it does not confirm that the sequel entered formal production. Without a known plot, studio commitment, or explanation for its fate, the report cannot establish how close the project came to being made.
Popular right now
Bose QuietComfort Wireless Noise Cancelling Headphones, Twilight Blue
Ninja Espresso and Coffee Maker with Built-In Frother, CFN601
De'Longhi All-in-One Espresso and Coffee Maker with 10-Cup Pot and Milk Frother
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Sequel Story Emerged
The original Elf stars Will Ferrell as Buddy, a human raised by elves who travels to meet his birth father, played by James Caan. The film’s premise and holiday popularity form the backdrop to Richter’s account, but the source material does not say that the reported sequel was officially commissioned or that its story continued Buddy’s narrative.
Richter has a direct connection to the film: he appeared in a small role and co-wrote Elf Unwrapped: Behind the Scenes of a Modern Christmas Classic, which Stereogum said was released the week before its report. He shared the sequel anecdote on the Obsessed podcast and again in a Page Six Radio interview. Those appearances are the reported basis for the story; further production records or comments from the people involved are not provided.
“The Edge reportedly wrote a sequel, and producer Shauna Robertson was approached about it.”
— Andy Richter, as recounted by Stereogum from his interviews
The Script’s Fate Remains Unknown
The source material leaves several central details unanswered. It does not identify the sequel’s plot, say when the Edge wrote it, or explain what Richter meant when he indicated that things did not work out. It is also unclear whether Robertson considered the script, whether a studio or rights-holder reviewed it, or how far discussions progressed.
No direct comment from the Edge, Robertson, or the studio appears in the report. Until those parties or additional documentation provide confirmation, the details should be treated as Richter’s account, not a fully documented production history. The material also does not say whether the script could be revisited or whether it remains available.
Further Comment Could Clarify
The next useful development would be comment from the Edge, Robertson, or representatives connected to Elf that could confirm the script’s history and explain why it did not move ahead. No such statement or future production plan is included in the available reporting. For now, the sequel remains a reported, unmade project with no disclosed plot or confirmed path to production.
Key Questions
Who says the Elf sequel was written?
Andy Richter shared the account on The Daily Beast’s Obsessed podcast and later on Page Six Radio, according to Stereogum. The source material does not include independent confirmation from the Edge.
What was the sequel about?
Richter did not reveal the sequel’s plot. The available report does not describe its characters or say whether it would have continued Buddy’s story.
Why was the sequel never made?
No clear reason is given. Stereogum reported that Richter’s account suggested things simply did not work out, without specifying what stopped the project.
Was the sequel officially approved or filmed?
The source says the script was reportedly fully written and that Robertson was approached. It does not establish that a studio approved the film, that production began, or that any scenes were shot.
Source: stereogum.com
